Shop old-style toilet flapper

Sponsored
$9.38
2-Inch Universal Toilet Tank Flapper, Toilet Flapper Replacement, Toilet Plug Flapper Compatible With Most American Standard Toilet Tank
Amazon.com
2
$9.38
2-Inch Universal Toilet Tank Flapper, Toilet Flapper Replacement, Toilet Plug Flapper Compatible With Most American Standard Toilet Tank
Amazon.com
2
$9.99
3-Inch Toilet Flapper Replacement For TOTO Toilet Tank Plug Flapper, Compatible With TOTO Flapper Model G-Max, THU138S, THU175S And THU331S, Easy To
Amazon.com
$9.99
3-Inch Toilet Flapper Replacement For TOTO Toilet Tank Plug Flapper, Compatible With TOTO Flapper Model G-Max, THU138S, THU175S And THU331S, Easy To
Amazon.com
$9.98
Toilet Flapper Replacement For Gerber, 2 Pack 3 Inch Compatible With Gerber 99-788 With 2 Toilet Handle Chains Rubber Water Saving, Easy To Install
Amazon.com
108
$9.98
Toilet Flapper Replacement For Gerber, 2 Pack 3 Inch Compatible With Gerber 99-788 With 2 Toilet Handle Chains Rubber Water Saving, Easy To Install
Amazon.com
108
$9.99
1 Pack 3-Inch Toilet Flapper Replacement Compatible With TOTO Flapper Model G-Max, THU138S, THU175S And THU331S
Amazon.com
5
$9.99
1 Pack 3-Inch Toilet Flapper Replacement Compatible With TOTO Flapper Model G-Max, THU138S, THU175S And THU331S
Amazon.com
5
$35.00
American Standard 7381657-200.0070A Vormax Toilet Flapper Assembly, Black
Amazon.com
1K+
Free shipping
$35.00
American Standard 7381657-200.0070A Vormax Toilet Flapper Assembly, Black
Amazon.com
1K+
$18.89
3 Inch Toilet Flapper Replacement Compatible With Gerber 99-788, Rubber Toilet Flapper Replacement Kit With Stainless Chain, Water-Saving Toilet
Amazon.com
$18.89
3 Inch Toilet Flapper Replacement Compatible With Gerber 99-788, Rubber Toilet Flapper Replacement Kit With Stainless Chain, Water-Saving Toilet
Amazon.com
$17.48
Fluidmaster Universal Toilet Fill Valve And 2-In Flapper Kit | K-400H-039-T14
Lowe's
In store
389
Curbside
$17.48
Fluidmaster Universal Toilet Fill Valve And 2-In Flapper Kit | K-400H-039-T14
Lowe's
389
$18.87
Fluidmaster 502CN3 Performax Universal Water-Saving Long Life Toilet Flapper For 2-Inch Flush Valves, Adjustable Solid Frame Design, Easy Install, 3
Amazon.com
16K+
$18.87
Fluidmaster 502CN3 Performax Universal Water-Saving Long Life Toilet Flapper For 2-Inch Flush Valves, Adjustable Solid Frame Design, Easy Install, 3
Amazon.com
16K+
$22.58
Korky 3062, 2 Pack Large 3-Inch Premium Toilet Flapper Long Lasting Rubber-Easy To Install-Made In USA, Red
Amazon.com
1
$22.58
Korky 3062, 2 Pack Large 3-Inch Premium Toilet Flapper Long Lasting Rubber-Easy To Install-Made In USA, Red
Amazon.com
1
$20.98
Fluidmaster Universal Toilet Fill Valve And 3-In Flapper Kit | K-400H-040-T5
Lowe's
In store
35
Curbside
$20.98
Fluidmaster Universal Toilet Fill Valve And 3-In Flapper Kit | K-400H-040-T5
Lowe's
35
$16.99
$19.67
Danco Hydroforce Premium Adjustable Toilet Flapper 7.3 H X 6.3 W X 2.0 D, Rubber In Blue | 2.0" L X 6.3" W X 7.3" H | Wayfair
Wayfair
157
13% off
$16.99
$19.67
Danco Hydroforce Premium Adjustable Toilet Flapper 7.3 H X 6.3 W X 2.0 D, Rubber In Blue | 2.0" L X 6.3" W X 7.3" H | Wayfair
Wayfair
157
$22.98
American Standard 4-In Black Plastic Flush Valve Repair Kit For Champion Toilet Models | 7381967-400.0070AP
Lowe's
In store
1
Curbside
$22.98
American Standard 4-In Black Plastic Flush Valve Repair Kit For Champion Toilet Models | 7381967-400.0070AP
Lowe's
1
$17.48
Fluidmaster Universal Toilet Fill Valve And 2-In Flapper Kit | 402C
Lowe's
In store
Curbside
$17.48
Fluidmaster Universal Toilet Fill Valve And 2-In Flapper Kit | 402C
Lowe's
$4.00
Flapper To Fit Kohler 1.6 Toilet - Wal-Rich Corporation
Getpipe.com
$4.00
Flapper To Fit Kohler 1.6 Toilet - Wal-Rich Corporation
Getpipe.com
$17.99
Hibbent 2 Pack Large 3-Inch Toilet Flapper Replacement Compatible With TOTO Flapper Model THU140S- Oversized Sealing And Easy To Install- Blue
Amazon.com
401
$17.99
Hibbent 2 Pack Large 3-Inch Toilet Flapper Replacement Compatible With TOTO Flapper Model THU140S- Oversized Sealing And Easy To Install- Blue
Amazon.com
401
$11.75
American Standard 738920-0070A Toilet Flapper
Craft Supply
$11.75
American Standard 738920-0070A Toilet Flapper
Craft Supply
$20.81
$40.80
40316 - 2 in. Coast Style Toilet Flapper (Pack Of 10) - Ez-Flo
Laundry Owners Warehouse
48% off
$20.81
$40.80
40316 - 2 in. Coast Style Toilet Flapper (Pack Of 10) - Ez-Flo
Laundry Owners Warehouse
$11.62
Toto 3" Universal Toilet Tank Flapper - THU500S
PlumbersStock
1
$11.62
Toto 3" Universal Toilet Tank Flapper - THU500S
PlumbersStock
1
$20.99
Toilet Flapper Universal Type 513A-016-P4, Plumbing Supplies, Toilet Parts
Agri Supply
$20.99
Toilet Flapper Universal Type 513A-016-P4, Plumbing Supplies, Toilet Parts
Agri Supply
$6.30
2 Universal Flapper
Craft Supply
$6.30
2 Universal Flapper
Craft Supply
$1.64
Blue Flapper To Fit American Standard - Wal-Rich Corporation
Getpipe.com
$1.64
Blue Flapper To Fit American Standard - Wal-Rich Corporation
Getpipe.com
$12.99
Hibbent 2 Pack 2-Inch Universal Toilet Tank Flapper, Long Lasting All Rubber Seal Flapper Replacement Compatible With American Standard Water
Amazon.com
$12.99
Hibbent 2 Pack 2-Inch Universal Toilet Tank Flapper, Long Lasting All Rubber Seal Flapper Replacement Compatible With American Standard Water
Amazon.com
$11.09
3 2022BP Toilet Flapper Repairs Large, Blue
Craft Supply
$11.09
3 2022BP Toilet Flapper Repairs Large, Blue
Craft Supply
$7.49
Toilet Flapper Tank Ball Thermplastic 501P21, Plumbing Supplies, Toilet Parts
Agri Supply
$7.49
Toilet Flapper Tank Ball Thermplastic 501P21, Plumbing Supplies, Toilet Parts
Agri Supply
$9.49
Toilet Flapper Adjust-A-Flush 502P21, Plumbing Supplies, Toilet Parts
Agri Supply
$9.49
Toilet Flapper Adjust-A-Flush 502P21, Plumbing Supplies, Toilet Parts
Agri Supply
$5.99
Tank Ball Toilet Microband 1 in. Flapper 500P21, Plumbing Supplies, Toilet Parts
Agri Supply
$5.99
Tank Ball Toilet Microband 1 in. Flapper 500P21, Plumbing Supplies, Toilet Parts
Agri Supply
$21.99
Hibbent 3 Pack Large 3-Inch Toilet Flapper Replacement Compatible With Gerber 99-788, Water Conserving Toilet Flappers For 3 Inch Flush Valves,
Amazon.com
1K+
$21.99
Hibbent 3 Pack Large 3-Inch Toilet Flapper Replacement Compatible With Gerber 99-788, Water Conserving Toilet Flappers For 3 Inch Flush Valves,
Amazon.com
1K+
$38.50
$55.00
American Standard Vormax Toilet Flapper Assembly 3.0 H X 5.5 W X 7.0 D, Silicone In Black | 7.0" L X 5.5" W X 3.0" H | Wayfair
Wayfair
30% off
$38.50
$55.00
American Standard Vormax Toilet Flapper Assembly 3.0 H X 5.5 W X 7.0 D, Silicone In Black | 7.0" L X 5.5" W X 3.0" H | Wayfair
Wayfair
$12.66
LARSEN SUPPLY CO. INC. Toilet Tank Flapper With Chain American Standard Cadet 3-In. 04-1609
DkHardware.com
1
$12.66
LARSEN SUPPLY CO. INC. Toilet Tank Flapper With Chain American Standard Cadet 3-In. 04-1609
DkHardware.com
1
$15.83
LARSEN SUPPLY CO. INC. Toto-Style Toilet Flapper Blue 3-In. 04-2151
DkHardware.com
11
$15.83
LARSEN SUPPLY CO. INC. Toto-Style Toilet Flapper Blue 3-In. 04-2151
DkHardware.com
11
$8.57
3" Flapper To Fit Mansfield - Wal-Rich Corporation
Getpipe.com
$8.57
3" Flapper To Fit Mansfield - Wal-Rich Corporation
Getpipe.com
$16.92
Fluidmaster 502 Performax Universal High Performance, Water-Saving 2" Flapper, New, Rubber, 6 in Height, 0.11 Lb.
Walmart
334
Free shipping
$16.92
Fluidmaster 502 Performax Universal High Performance, Water-Saving 2" Flapper, New, Rubber, 6 in Height, 0.11 Lb.
Walmart
334
$3.02
LARSEN SUPPLY CO. INC. Toilet Flapper Chain With Foam Float Kohler 04-1525
DkHardware.com
$3.02
LARSEN SUPPLY CO. INC. Toilet Flapper Chain With Foam Float Kohler 04-1525
DkHardware.com
$15.99
Fluidmaster Super Flapper 6.0 H X 2.5 D, Rubber | Wayfair
Wayfair
446
$15.99
Fluidmaster Super Flapper 6.0 H X 2.5 D, Rubber | Wayfair
Wayfair
446
$18.79
Fluidmaster PRO58 Flapper - Wal-Rich Corporation
Getpipe.com
$18.79
Fluidmaster PRO58 Flapper - Wal-Rich Corporation
Getpipe.com
$8.86
3" Flapper To Fit American Standard "Cadet " - Wal-Rich Corporation
Getpipe.com
$8.86
3" Flapper To Fit American Standard "Cadet " - Wal-Rich Corporation
Getpipe.com
See more
See less
    Some results have been hidden because they may be inaccessible to you.Show inaccessible results
    See more images

    Shop old-style toilet flapper

    Sponsored
    $9.38
    2-Inch Universal Toilet Tank Flapper, Toilet Flapper Replacement, Toilet Plug Flapper Compatible With Most American Standard Toilet Tank
    Amazon.com
    2
    $9.38
    2-Inch Universal Toilet Tank Flapper, Toilet Flapper Replacement, Toilet Plug Flapper Compatible With Most American Standard Toilet Tank
    Amazon.com
    2
    $9.99
    3-Inch Toilet Flapper Replacement For TOTO Toilet Tank Plug Flapper, Compatible With TOTO Flapper Model G-Max, THU138S, THU175S And THU331S, Easy To
    Amazon.com
    $9.99
    3-Inch Toilet Flapper Replacement For TOTO Toilet Tank Plug Flapper, Compatible With TOTO Flapper Model G-Max, THU138S, THU175S And THU331S, Easy To
    Amazon.com
    $9.98
    Toilet Flapper Replacement For Gerber, 2 Pack 3 Inch Compatible With Gerber 99-788 With 2 Toilet Handle Chains Rubber Water Saving, Easy To Install
    Amazon.com
    108
    $9.98
    Toilet Flapper Replacement For Gerber, 2 Pack 3 Inch Compatible With Gerber 99-788 With 2 Toilet Handle Chains Rubber Water Saving, Easy To Install
    Amazon.com
    108
    $9.99
    1 Pack 3-Inch Toilet Flapper Replacement Compatible With TOTO Flapper Model G-Max, THU138S, THU175S And THU331S
    Amazon.com
    5
    $9.99
    1 Pack 3-Inch Toilet Flapper Replacement Compatible With TOTO Flapper Model G-Max, THU138S, THU175S And THU331S
    Amazon.com
    5
    $35.00
    American Standard 7381657-200.0070A Vormax Toilet Flapper Assembly, Black
    Amazon.com
    1K+
    Free shipping
    $35.00
    American Standard 7381657-200.0070A Vormax Toilet Flapper Assembly, Black
    Amazon.com
    1K+
    $18.89
    3 Inch Toilet Flapper Replacement Compatible With Gerber 99-788, Rubber Toilet Flapper Replacement Kit With Stainless Chain, Water-Saving Toilet
    Amazon.com
    $18.89
    3 Inch Toilet Flapper Replacement Compatible With Gerber 99-788, Rubber Toilet Flapper Replacement Kit With Stainless Chain, Water-Saving Toilet
    Amazon.com
    $17.48
    Fluidmaster Universal Toilet Fill Valve And 2-In Flapper Kit | K-400H-039-T14
    Lowe's
    In store
    389
    Curbside
    $17.48
    Fluidmaster Universal Toilet Fill Valve And 2-In Flapper Kit | K-400H-039-T14
    Lowe's
    389
    $18.87
    Fluidmaster 502CN3 Performax Universal Water-Saving Long Life Toilet Flapper For 2-Inch Flush Valves, Adjustable Solid Frame Design, Easy Install, 3
    Amazon.com
    16K+
    $18.87
    Fluidmaster 502CN3 Performax Universal Water-Saving Long Life Toilet Flapper For 2-Inch Flush Valves, Adjustable Solid Frame Design, Easy Install, 3
    Amazon.com
    16K+
    $22.58
    Korky 3062, 2 Pack Large 3-Inch Premium Toilet Flapper Long Lasting Rubber-Easy To Install-Made In USA, Red
    Amazon.com
    1
    $22.58
    Korky 3062, 2 Pack Large 3-Inch Premium Toilet Flapper Long Lasting Rubber-Easy To Install-Made In USA, Red
    Amazon.com
    1
    $20.98
    Fluidmaster Universal Toilet Fill Valve And 3-In Flapper Kit | K-400H-040-T5
    Lowe's
    In store
    35
    Curbside
    $20.98
    Fluidmaster Universal Toilet Fill Valve And 3-In Flapper Kit | K-400H-040-T5
    Lowe's
    35
    $16.99
    $19.67
    Danco Hydroforce Premium Adjustable Toilet Flapper 7.3 H X 6.3 W X 2.0 D, Rubber In Blue | 2.0" L X 6.3" W X 7.3" H | Wayfair
    Wayfair
    157
    13% off
    $16.99
    $19.67
    Danco Hydroforce Premium Adjustable Toilet Flapper 7.3 H X 6.3 W X 2.0 D, Rubber In Blue | 2.0" L X 6.3" W X 7.3" H | Wayfair
    Wayfair
    157
    $22.98
    American Standard 4-In Black Plastic Flush Valve Repair Kit For Champion Toilet Models | 7381967-400.0070AP
    Lowe's
    In store
    1
    Curbside
    $22.98
    American Standard 4-In Black Plastic Flush Valve Repair Kit For Champion Toilet Models | 7381967-400.0070AP
    Lowe's
    1
    $17.48
    Fluidmaster Universal Toilet Fill Valve And 2-In Flapper Kit | 402C
    Lowe's
    In store
    Curbside
    $17.48
    Fluidmaster Universal Toilet Fill Valve And 2-In Flapper Kit | 402C
    Lowe's
    $4.00
    Flapper To Fit Kohler 1.6 Toilet - Wal-Rich Corporation
    Getpipe.com
    $4.00
    Flapper To Fit Kohler 1.6 Toilet - Wal-Rich Corporation
    Getpipe.com
    $17.99
    Hibbent 2 Pack Large 3-Inch Toilet Flapper Replacement Compatible With TOTO Flapper Model THU140S- Oversized Sealing And Easy To Install- Blue
    Amazon.com
    401
    $17.99
    Hibbent 2 Pack Large 3-Inch Toilet Flapper Replacement Compatible With TOTO Flapper Model THU140S- Oversized Sealing And Easy To Install- Blue
    Amazon.com
    401
    $11.75
    American Standard 738920-0070A Toilet Flapper
    Craft Supply
    $11.75
    American Standard 738920-0070A Toilet Flapper
    Craft Supply
    $20.81
    $40.80
    40316 - 2 in. Coast Style Toilet Flapper (Pack Of 10) - Ez-Flo
    Laundry Owners Warehouse
    48% off
    $20.81
    $40.80
    40316 - 2 in. Coast Style Toilet Flapper (Pack Of 10) - Ez-Flo
    Laundry Owners Warehouse
    $11.62
    Toto 3" Universal Toilet Tank Flapper - THU500S
    PlumbersStock
    1
    $11.62
    Toto 3" Universal Toilet Tank Flapper - THU500S
    PlumbersStock
    1